Lukas' Notes

Definition

Berry's Paradox

Berry’s paradox is a semantic paradox of unrestricted, self-applicable definability.

Fix a finite English vocabulary containing the words below, and let denote the positive natural numbers:

Finitely many short descriptions make finite; infinitely many positive integers make its complement non-empty.

Taking gives “the least positive integer not definable in under eleven words”. By construction, , hence . Yet this ten-word description appears to specify uniquely, giving : a contradiction.

The problem is unrestricted self-applicable definability, not arithmetic: a description about a precise language’s definability need not be an admissible definition within that language.